What's Hot | Search

Get Your Personal
On-Air Report Here
 
Welcome to the temporary home of Michael Medved.com.
Stay tuned for a new and improved website, coming soon!
Wednesday, June 20, 2007
Michael Medved :: Townhall.com Columnist
Free The Palestinians: Let Them Find Homes Among Their Arab Brothers
by Michael Medved
Vote on It:
Average Vote:
[+] Text [-]
 

All people of good will feel anguished over the humanitarian catastrophe in Gaza, but those who honestly wish to help the suffering Palestinians can endorse only one potential solution: allow the desperate residents to escape from their Hamas-ruled hell-on-earth to find new homes elsewhere among their Arab brothers.

In no sense would this constitute a forced migration: normal, sane human beings hardly require force or even encouragement in order to flee from the wretched realities of today’s Gaza Strip. In nearby Iraq, some two million people have left their homes and run away from ongoing violence to reestablish themselves in Jordan, Syria and elsewhere. Why would anyone want to deny the same choice to the Palestinians – who live under far more abject and long-standing poverty (with no oil resources), and under the rule of even more demented Islamist fanatics? In fact, the surviving opponents of the malevolent crazies of Hamas have every reason to fear for their lives, and face ongoing threats of the same gruesome fates as their compatriots who’ve been dragged through the streets, or thrown from tall buildings, or gunned down in front of wives and children.

Last week, when Hamas gunmen fired indiscriminately into a non-violent, non-aligned peace demonstration pleading for reconciliation and brotherhood among Palestinian factions, they established their bona fides as bloodthirsty maniacs. Some residents of Gaza might welcome the “perfect Islamic justice” they promise to impose, but most others would no doubt prefer to find homes elsewhere in the Middle East.

America’s top priority in the area ought to be a concerted effort to help them do so.

Some Palestinian sympathizers might insist that these new Middle Eastern refugees should get the chance to relocate in only one country: Israel. After all, most Gazans claim that they once lived in the Holy Land, or that their great-great grandfathers once lived there, and they insist that the very existence of the thriving democracy to their east as the illegitimate occupation of their sacred Palestinian birthright.

It is this very refusal to accept Israel’s reality in any terms (part of a sixty year history of self-destructive Arab rejectionism) that makes it unthinkable for the Jewish state to welcome the suffering multitudes of Gaza. After all, voters in the West Bank split more evenly between Fatah and Hamas in the recent Palestinian elections, but the residents of Gaza voted overwhelmingly for Hamas: the fundamentalist terror organization that pledges in its charter to resist forever the right of Jews to even “one square inch” of their ancient homeland.

Moreover, the idea of resettling Palestinians in today’s Israel means bringing people to a society where 80% of the inhabitants practice a different religion, speak a different language, uphold different values, and exist in a different century (the 21st century as opposed to the 7th).

Since so many Gazans want desperately to leave, doesn’t it make more sense to relocate them among their fellow Arabs, who practice exactly the same religion (they’re nearly all Sunni Moslems), speak the same language, honor the same traditions, claim identical histories, and embrace the same pan-Arab nationalism? If Jordan and Syria accept hundreds of thousands of Iraqi refugees, why not Palestinians from Gaza, who would fit into the host societies at least as easily as the Iraqis? (Jordan already boasts a clear Palestinian majority). Meanwhile, Egypt is a nation of some 70,000,000 which actually ruled the Gaza Strip for nineteen years (1948-1967) and many of the so-called Palestinians actually originated in Egypt --including the most famous “Palestinian” of them all, Yasser Arafat who was born and raised in Cairo, and spent most of his young manhood in Kuwait.

And speaking of Kuwait, Saudi Arabia and the Gulf States currently suffer an acute labor shortage, and import workers from all over the world to sustain their economies. Instead of bringing in more laborers from Pakistan or Rumania or the Philippines, why not invite the Palestinians to escape the enduring misery of Gaza? Continued...

1 2
| Full Article & Comments | Next >
Share:
Vote on It:
Average Vote:
 
About The Author
Michael Medved's daily syndicated radio talk show reaches one of the largest national audiences every weekday between 3 and 6 PM, Eastern Time. Michael Medved is the author of eleven books, including the bestsellers What Really Happened to the Class of '65?, Hollywood vs. America, Right Turns and, most recently, The Ten Big Lies About America.
 
TOWNHALL DAILY: Be the first to read Michael Medved's column. Sign up today and receive Townhall.com daily lineup delivered each morning to your inbox.
Hat handed to Medved
Why read this guy's column anymore? He's lost his credibility with me. This guy destroyed Medved's nasty insulting arguments on the North American Union.

http://www.humanevents.com/article.php?id=18721

I see I'm not alone in thinking Medved has been in a steady mental decline in the last year or so. Brain tumor? Pending divorce? Something's changed. Or has the veneer just come off?

Re Palestinians etc
This tired claim that Israel offered the Palestinians 98% etc is undercut by a few facts. To begin with, the West Bank was to be cut up into cantons divided by Jews-only roads. Israel was to control Palestine's borders and Palestine was to be denied normal air and water rights. Moreover, the plan was never fully presented. When the going got rough, Israel walked away, saying (as it always does) that the Palestinians were to blame etc. But then began the false propaganda barrage, which millions believed.

Since the three US delegates all were pro-Zionists (all Jewish), they naturally blamed Arafat. You'd think that the US would have been smart enough to send a delegation that was essentually neutral, willing to listen to both sides with the same degree of open-mindedness. You certainly can't expect that of Dennis Ross. And now we are continuously subjected to all sorts of Israel-first propagandists on TV and radio.

Now, I'm sure some of you are wagging your heads and calling me a dirty anti-Semite. That's the usual reaction to anyone who champions the Palestinians. I champion both sides, because both sides are right. And both have been wrong. The Israelis have been stupid to keep building settlements on the West Bank. How is that justified except to bizarre Bible worshipers? (I worship God and no vague prophecies from any book.) Palestinian terrorism has been wrong, also, though the Israeli military certainly has been guilty of lots of state terrorism. I wish that the Palestinians had followed the example of Gandhi and King instead of confronting violence with violence.

The only hope for Israel in the long run is a fair, negotiated peace, then living in mutual prosperity with its Palestine neighbor. Despite racist nonsense, the Palestinians have been a progressive people. Decades of frustration - plus Fatah corruption - led them to vote in Hamas. Nothing but a prosperous Palestinian state (sharply opposed for years by Israel) has a possibility of working. The main obstacle to this is the Israeli lobby which hasn't permitted the USA to be an effective mediator.

In sum, AIPAC and its allies are the principal enemies of Israel. Sounds strange, but it's sadly true. I hope it's not too late. I am devoutly religious and Israel is my Holy Land. I want it to survive and prosper. But the vast Muslim world and many others are so angry with Israel and its brutal occupation and arrogance that it could be too late. If so, much of the blame is with AIPAC & Co.
Note: Fields marked with a red asterisk (*) are required.
Salutation:
First Name:
*
Last Name:
*
Email:
*
Nickname:
*
Note: Nick name will be shown when you post comments.
Address 1:
*
Address 2:
City:
*
State:
*
Zip:
*
Phone:
      
Your daily must-read of conservative columns, cartoons and news. Coulter, Sowell, Krauthammer and more.
(Bi-Weekly) We highlight the best opportunities from our partners for surveys, action items and more.